hans scholl geschwister

Pedophilia is a persistent sexual attraction to prepubescent children. For him, the spiritual fathers are clearly Hans Scholl and Alexander Schmorell. He told police he could only explain it in terms of the great love he felt for his friend. So, the only reason charges were brought against Hans—while his siblings spent a few days in jail and were released—were due to the sexual nature of his relationship with Rolf. The Geschwister-Scholl-Preis is a literary prize which is awarded annually by the Bavarian chapter of the Börsenverein des Deutschen Buchhandels and the city of Munich. De guillotine werd aangetroffen in het depot van het Beiers Nationaal Museum in München en bleek daar al sinds 1947 te staan. atd: 2021-01-18 01:38 lt (utc +1) eta: 2021-01-27 15:00 lt (utc +3) past track. So, there was no attempt to set the record straight and most accounts of the White Rose leave out the important role gay issues played in the conception of the group. So, even as the family attempted to alter history by hiding this relationship, they weren’t careful enough and small slips can be detected. After his trial for his relationship with Rolf, Hans struggled emotionally with his own sexuality. Sachs is at war with the Scholl family. Hans Fritz Scholl (født 22. september 1918, død 22. februar 1943) var sammen med søsteren Sophie Scholl medlem af den tyske modstandsgruppe Weiße Rose.. Han blev tillige med søsteren og Christoph Probst dødsdømt i München den 22. februar 1943. Hans en Sophie Scholl, boegbeelden van het Duitse verzet . Dit verslag is op 21 december 2011 gepubliceerd op Scholieren.com en gemaakt door een scholier (4e klas vmbo) In many cases it is extraneous material being deleted. You can see what I mean in that one disgusting sentence. To then show she isn’t accusing them of incest she suggests another possible explanation — which again shows Sachs to be sexually obsessed. This included Inge Scholl (b. While I had read histories of the White Rose it was only when Jud Newborn wrote a addendum to his book Sophie Scholl and The White Rose that I learned the true origins of the group. Symbolically, the Scholl Institute is located in the building that had housed Radio Free Europe. She says the unknown is the “how or when” it happened, not whether it happened. For Hans his move away from National Socialism toward a more liberal approach began years before when he was passionately in love with Rolf Futterknecht, a young man in the same youth group as himself. The Geschwister-Scholl-Preis is a literary prize initiated by the State Association of Bavaria of the Börsenverein des Deutschen Buchhandels and the city of Munich. My reading of the facts indicates it wasn’t Hans who kept this “secret” so much as his sister Inga. The transcripts show, contrary to Sachs’ claims, Rolf was older than she claimed, and barely more than a year’s difference in age existed between the two boys. Hans Scholl. His sister had read it. It simply is not pedophilia for someone 16 to have a sexual relationship with someone 15. De familie Scholl verhuisde enkele keren: Forchtenberg, Ludwigsburg en Ulm. Now, there is no doubt Inga Scholl (now deceased) did her best to hide certain facts from the public — such as her pretending the first trial of Hans had nothing to do with a gay relationship. Even when the diaries of Scholl were released, they were edited and references to his sexual relationships were deleted. The two boys were sitting on the couch petting. Zoske is of the opinion that it is wrong to put the “Geschwister Scholl” at the center of the White Rose. More importantly “pedophilia” is a clinical term and when properly defined does not apply to Hans Scholl. In the Thuringian town of Flurstedt, there is even a Geschwister-Scholl fountain. The prize commemorates Sophie and Hans Scholl, who belonged to the student resistance group 'Weiße Rose' in Munich during the Nazi era and were later murdered by the National Socialists. Reden, however, did serve six months in a concentration camp for his violation of Paragraph 175. In addition, many schools, libraries, streets, and public squares throughout Germany are named for the Scholl siblings. I suspect most readers of the published letters of Hans and Sophie were unaware of the third set of charges under ¶175, and would not notice this, when the comments actually only make sense in light of those charges. In Sachs’ mind that is “a confession” and one she takes literally. Hans Scholl, Sophie Scholl, Prof. Kurt Huber Christoph Probst , Alexander Schmorell, Willi Graf 61 Sophie Scholls Wohnorte. SITE PLAN SECTIONS CLASSROOM PLAN CLASSROOM SECTION WATERCOLOURS MODEL PHOTOS. Hans, of course, never had the option of restating things after the war since the Nazis beheaded him for his resistance activity. However, a proposal by the student government to rename the university "Geschwister Scholl University" was rejected by the university's leadership. Inga Scholl, in her book on her siblings, left out all references to the actual charges. Scholl was infatuated with another member of the group, Rolf Futterknecht. They are also extremely expensive. Reden, who was older than Hans, had been briefly sexually involved with Werner Scholl, a younger brother. Since 1997, a memorial to the Scholl siblings and other members of the White Rose can be found in the atrium of the main building, and since 2005, a bronze bust of Sophie Scholl. Inform us! She knew nothing about it. Vater SCHOLL empfand die Machtübernahme durch HITLER im Jahre 1933 als etwas Bedrohliches. In post-war Germany, Hans and Sophie Scholl are recognized as symbols of the Christian German resistance movement against the totalitarian Nazi regime. The Geschwister-Scholl-Institut at the Ludwig Maximilians University of Munich has been named in honor of Sophie and Hans Scholl. It was designed by famous Berlin based architect Hans Scharoun and realised from 1956 to 1962. Jud Newborn told me he and Zoske both tried to encourage her to speak out with the truth, which he said is “not easy, she really doesn’t want to, as you know.”. Samme dag blev alle tre halshugget med guillotinen. Before the Nazis grabbed Hans and sentenced him to beheading for crimes against the state, he had been put on trial once before, for a gay relationship. Hänet pidätettiin 18. helmikuuta 1943, kun hän oli yliopistossa jakamassa järjestön lehtisiä. I suspect this had two motivations; the first was his close friendship to Josef, which he downplayed with the Nazis, and the second was because the bookstore was where they hid the printing press they used. Hans (1918-1943) und Sophie Scholl (1921-1943) wurden zusammen mit ihren drei Geschwistern von ihren Eltern nach christlich-humanitären Werten erzogen. I saw something on the German site Focus on Hans Scholl that gives me some hope. Other articles where Hans Scholl is discussed: White Rose: …of the group’s founding members—Hans Scholl, Willi Graf, and Alexander Schmorell—were medical students at the University of Munich. The area in front of the university's main building is named Geschwister-Scholl-Platz. add to fleet. The Scholl siblings had been arrested three days earlier and undergone nearly constant interrogation by the Gestapo before their trial. He died on February 22, 1943 in Stadelheim Prison, Munich, Bavaria, Germany. Sophie was not involved at all in the beginning. The boys were released under the amnesty, thank God… Application is being made to put Ernst Reden on trial and remand him in custody…. She even goes into telling irrelevent stories about herself — as if she matters in this history. But, the family did allow references in the diaries that alluded to the relationship, I presume on the assumption people would only associate them with the charges they previously mentioned. The third trial is one in the court of public opinion. He said as much during questioning after his arrest. * 22. For him, the spiritual fathers are clearly Hans Scholl and Alexander Schmorell. There is no “American law” on age of consent, but each state or jurisdiction has it’s own. Find the perfect geschwister_scholl stock photo. Hans was not 17 going on 18, he was 16 going on 17. Hans (1918-1943) und Sophie Scholl (1921-1943) wurden zusammen mit ihren drei Geschwistern von ihren Eltern nach christlich-humanitären Werten erzogen. On February 18, 1943, two of the siblings, Hans and Sophie, were handing out flyers at the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, when they were caught by the custodian, Jakob Schmid, who informed the Gestapo. Prezi’s Staff Picks: Stakeholder management, sales, and efficiency One amateur historian, Ruth Sachs, has gone out of her way to smear and attack Hans and the entire Scholl family. The relationship between Hans and Rolf appears to be the reason the White Rose was eventually conceived. Once she got out Hans had a relationship with this other boy she turns him into a full-time “pervert” who apparently would shag anything in sight. While there is good reason to assume the group was named after the banned book, The White Rose, Scholl pretended the name had no meaning, probably because Söhngen’s bookstore was a source of banned books for trusted friends. The last flyer of the White Rose is set in the ground. Not all sex between “minors” is illegal, and numerous states have “Romeo and Juliet” provisions for minors of similar age. ‘Was that friendship or love?’ Perhaps the erotic dimension was missing, but it certainly was love too,’ concludes Zoske.” And it is Scholl and Schmorell who Focus called the “spiritual fathers” of the White Rose. HANS war zu diesem Zeitpunkt 15 Jahre alt, SOPHIE 12 Jahre alt, und zum ersten Mal trat Politik in ihr Leben. On camping trips Hans said he and Rolf “slept with our arms around each other” and he loved Rolf. Hans specifically said his mother didn’t see anything. Anklageschrift gegen Hans Scholl, Sophie Scholl und Christoph Probst.pdf 1,240 × 1,753, 10 pages; 7.94 MB De-Hans Scholl.ogg 2.0 s; 19 KB Denkmal für die Geschwister Scholl und Christoph Probst als Teil des Weiße-Rose-Mahnmals.jpg 5,472 × 3,648; 5.53 MB She continues with her smear that Hans was a “pedophile” and “molester;” because as a teen he had a relationship with another teen. 2013: Heute vor 70 Jahren, am 18.2.1943, wurden die Geschwister Hans und Sophie Scholl in München von der Gestapo verhaftet. In addition, as we will see, the age she gives for Rolf is false. Zoske says Inga did this because she couldn’t see Hans being seen as heroic if people knew of his gay relationship. But Hans remained close friends with gay men in spite of the risk. My first thought was she wanted to be able to spend time with her boyfriend, and time with her brother, and not seeing them both at the same time, optimized her time with each. The judge said Rolf “was probably not inexperienced in such matters” and was “pre-disposed to them.” The judge was inclined to see this as a youthful indiscretion. Hans was arrested on three charges. Robert Scholl, the father, is repeatedly attacked as a philanderer. In 2005, a German television survey voted Hans and Sophie the fourth greatest Germans of all time. To make things more complicated she has an “academic version” and a “regular version” where content varies. hans scholl. Er freundet sich mit Alexander Schmorell (1917-1943) und Christoph Probst (1919-1943) an, mit denen er … One young woman, Traute Lafrenz was presented by the family as his “girlfriend.” Lafrenz has been silent about the actual nature of her relationship with Hans and especially about his sexual orientation until only recently. It would seem the one issue he felt he couldn’t justify to the court, but could justify to himself, was his relationship with Rolf. In: Die Gewissensentwicklung der Geschwister Scholl. It was, however, not until the 1998 law to abolish Nazi judgments of injustice in the administration of criminal justice that the sentences against Hans Scholl and other members of the White Rose became void in Germany. Sachs wrote Sophie’s letter “clues us in to an unwholesome development in Sophie’s bond with Hans. Update this biography » Complete biography of Hans Scholl » The arrests were also critical in turning the siblings against the Nazi state. Werner, however, was not receptive and after some brief kissing and fondling the two parted ways. Ernst remained a close family friend even after his conviction. The Battle That Saved Islam And Crushed The Mongols, The Conquest of the Americas: Killing in the Name of Jesus. Vielä samana kesänä Scholl osallistui Valkoisen ruusun lehtisten toimittamiseen. It would offend national sensibilities to consider an immature young man as the educator of a young person only 1–1/2 years his junior, especially when that [16–1/2 year old] young man is himself still developing morally.”. Inge Scholl, de zus van Hans en Sophie, heeft het verhaal na de oorlog opgeschreven. These are found in another binder of material, The Buendische Trials (Scholl/Reden) 1937–1938. Since other Scholl siblings were involved with the youth group they all got arrested but charges were dropped against them. Conscripted into the military while still going to university, Hans served both militarily and studied. They denied her access to all letters and such. 1918), Elisabeth Scholl (b. However, after his father was arrested and detained for speaking out politically, Hans and his siblings became more involved in actively resisting the Third Reich. In addition, just as she falsely lowers Rolf’s age, she falsely asserts Hans was older than he was, claiming he would turn 18 in September, 1935. "Why, the Führer is even being praised abroad! It states Scholl was 16 when the relationship began. Huge collection, amazing choice, 100+ million high quality, affordable RF and RM images. Sophie Scholl was just 21 years old when she was executed along with her brother, 24-year-old Hans Scholl, on Feb. 22, 1943. In his interrogations with police Hans admitted the nature of the relationship and recounted at least some of their sexual activities. Die naam, Geschwister Scholl (Afr: Die Scholl broer en suster), verwys na Hans en sy suster Sophie Scholl, wat deel was van die Münich-gebaseerde weerstands groep, Weiße Rose (Afr: wit roos), wat gedurende die Tweede Wêreldoorlog aktief was teen die Nasionaal Sosialistiese regering van Duitsland.Die groep het hulle lewens gewaag deur pamflette te versprei in Duitsland, wat eers om … Zoske is of the opinion that it is wrong to put the “Geschwister Scholl” at the center of the White Rose. "During the transport to the front their train had stopped for a few minutes at a Polish station. Shortly after this trial Scholl wrote in his diary, “If you tear our hearts from our bodies, you yourselves will burn to death for it.” While Hans died at the hands of the Nazis his prediction of a violent end to the Nazi regime proved accurate. The new Geschwister-Scholl-Institut for political science, founded in the post-war era, was named after them on January 30, 1968. Hans was ignored, but he was the founder and did the lion’s share of the work. (3) They lived in the little town of Forchtenberg on the River Kocher. As a result, they were both executed by guillotine. She falsely claims the Judge “blamed the victim” for “the assault.”. The students and their friends had distributed leaflets calling on people to resist the Nazi regime. He was incredibly happy after he was selected for the task. The two young men established a very close relationship, studied medicine together, and were sent together to a student assignment on the Eastern Front. ... Morgen is het precies 75 jaar geleden dat de Geschwister Scholl geëxecuteerd werden. unlock voyage information. Cite this chapter as: Keller G. (2014) Zeittafel: Hans und Sophie Scholl. He had realised that his personal beliefs were vastly different from those of the Hitler Youth. Born the son of Magdalena and Mayor Robert Scholl at Forchtenberg am Kocher, Germany. Hans Scholl war wie seine Geschwister gegen den erklärten Willen des Vaters zunächst ein begeistertes Mitglied der Hitler-Jugend und nahm Führungsposten im Jungvolk der Hitler-Jugend ein. April: Hans Scholl nimmt ein Medizinstudium an der Universität München auf, wo er Kontakt zu regimekritischen Studenten und Professoren findet. There was no victim and no assault. The true history was distorted with everyone concentrating on the role of Sophie Scholl. Every year, a book is honoured, which "shows intellectual independence and supports civil freedom, moral, intellectual and aesthetic courage and that gives an important impulse to the present awareness of responsibility". However, I fear in this case it was references to the crimes for which Reden and Scholl were both charged, violating ¶175, which were being deleted. But, she rarely passes up a chance to smear the Scholl family, even if she has to fantasize or distort facts to do so. Do the math yourself, his birth date was September 22, 1918. When Söhngen was interrogated by the Gestapo he repeatedly lied about his relationship with Scholl, saying Hans rarely spent time in his apartment. While on the Eastern Front, the trio observed the murder of Jewish civilians by SS troops. Hans and Sophie Scholl lived in the rear of this apartment-building, from June 1942 until their arrestment and execution, on 22 February 1943. I submitted a written recommendation that your son be released from custody….”. September 1918 Hans Scholl in Ingersheim (Schwaben)* 9. But I know of no public statement he made indicating this—no doubt due to legal reasons. Sophie was uninvolved in this until near the end. Siblings in the White Rose nonviolent anti-Nazi movement, Learn how and when to remove this template message, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hans_and_Sophie_Scholl&oldid=1001862334, People executed by Nazi Germany by guillotine, Articles lacking in-text citations from January 2021, Articles with German-language sources (de), Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 21 January 2021, at 18:58. (By boys I mean young men in their teens with just over 1 year’s age difference between them.). Hans Scholl werd op 22 september 1918 geboren in Ingersheim, waar zijn vader burgemeester was. Under American law in the 21st century, this is considered pedophilia.” She says, “The progression of events is clear and disturbing.”. Scholl was born in Ingersheim (now a part of Crailsheim, Baden-Württemberg).His father, Robert, later became the mayor of Forchtenberg am Kocher.Hans was the second of six children: Inge Aicher-Scholl (1917–1998); Hans Scholl (1918–1943) Elisabeth Scholl Hartnagel (born 1920), married Sophie's long-term boyfriend, Fritz Hartnagel. Hans og Sophie Scholl var længe de eneste ikke-kommunistiske oppositionelle fra nazi-tiden, der blev hædret af myndighederne i DDR. Sachs claimed Scholl sexually assaulted a young boy repeatedly and was a pedophile. Later he would do the same thing with his friend Josef Söhngen, the gay bookstore owner who helped hide the White Rose printing press in his basement. Hans was enrolled in the military service in spring of 1941 as a medic in France against Russia. Hans maximized his responsibility and, if he had been believed, would have exonerated Rolf to his own detriment. It was the show trial where in a matter of hours they were convicted and sentenced to almost immediate execution. Historian Jud Newborn wrote, “The Gestapo transcript reveals headstrong, garrulous testimony as Hans strove to justify himself while protecting Rolf from indictment.”. From 1935 to 1936 Hans and Rolf were very close, quite affectionate with one another and the relationship was clearly sexual — at least sexual enough charges were brought against the boys by the Nazis. Februar 1943 Flugblätter vor den Hörsälen im Hauptgebäude der Münchner Universität. In post-war Germany, Hans and Sophie Scholl are recognized as symbols of the Christian German resistance movement against the totalitarian Nazi regime. The history of the White Rose was again intimately connected to the issue of homosexuality. And, while Sachs says, in one place he was “not even thirteen,” implying he was twelve, and in another says he was thirteen, neither claim was true, he was older. He returned home disillusioned and confused and started to turn toward the more liberal thinkers his father had admired. In Jungvolk, where Scholl was a leader, Rolf was in a different squad but requested to be transferred to Scholl’s unit so they could be together. Sophie only discovered her brother was involved late in the game and the siblings may have survived the war had she never done so; a blunder on her part lead to their capture and execution. Geschwister Hans uind Sophie Scholl. Biography. Neljä päivää myöhemmin Sophie Scholl, hänen veljensä Hans Scholl ja heidän ystävänsä Christoph Probst tuomittiin kuolemaan. Hans Scholl, Actor: Die Prinzessin Suwarin. The court also said Rolf “was probably not inexperienced in such matters and pre-disposed to them.” Rolf also defended Hans and, also trying to paint things in the best legal light, telling the court Scholl often felt remorse for what they had done. Do NOT stop reading with only these accusations, as you will be left with a grossly distorted view of things. But in a telephone conversation on August 28, 2018, she finally explained that Hans had had a ‘deep problem’ that ‘plagued him greatly,’ but one which he had kept ‘dreadfully secret.’ He had attempted ‘to eliminate this conflict by focusing on higher ideals’ but could ‘never free himself of it.’ This burden was ‘so significant for him, that it had ‘formed his character profoundly.’. Yes, after his arrest he took measures to hide his sexual orientation from public view, including being seen dating young women, which makes perfect sense given a further offense would send him to a concentration camp. In her White Rose History, Volume 1 she writes, “One of the most controversial topics in the academic version only centers on Hans Scholl’s pedophilia.” She says, “The details make it clear that his [Hans] assaults were escalating and that his advances (and remember, “Robert” was only thirteen) were unwelcome.” She calls Rolf by the pseudonym Robert. The prosecution claimed Hans was an educational leader who corrupted the other boy. …Somehow their closeness had evolved into conduct that more strongly suggests a tie between boyfriend and girlfriend, not brother and sister. Hans Scholl was obligated to spend his holidays away from University as a medic for combat duty during the war. Source. In her interrogation Sophie openly told the SS she turned against the Nazi regime when her brother was arrested for his relationship with Rolf. When Hans did the same thing regarding White Rose activities, and lied to the Gestapo to protect friends, she doesn’t argue it proves he was the only White Rose member. Sophie Scholl was just 21 years old when she was executed along with her brother, 24-year-old Hans Scholl, on Feb. 22, 1943. Das Ulmer Jungvolk, dem sich Hans Scholl im Oktober 1933 anschloss, war … Weitere Ideen zu Weiße rose, Geschwister scholl, Die weiße rose. She later discovered a copy of the works of the classical liberal Friedrich von Schiller in her brother’s room. The couple married and over the next few years Magdalena gave birth to six children. Scharoun applied the principles of organic architecture and focused on the children’s needs and stages of development . By February 22, 1943, they had been sentenced to death by the People's Court, led by Judge-President Roland Freisler and were executed by guillotine on the same day in the Stadelheim Prison. Like a wacky conspiracy theorist she uses the reaction to her nonsense as proof her accusations must be true. To begin with, a Jungsvolk Squad Leader is a subordinate position. On top of that, the relationship would not necessarily be illegal in all American states. Filmverslag van de film Sophie Scholl - Die letzten Tage (2005) voor het vak duits en de methode Neue Kontakte. So he was intimately familiar with the poet Ernst Reden and the bookseller Josef Söhngen — both homosexual — and lived for months with Hellmut Hartert, a fellow student, in a tiny attic and a snow-covered holiday room.”. All American law does is define a sexual age of consent; it does not try to legally define psychological terms. fr set sete. 28.05.2013 - Hier sammeln wir Bilder und Texte im Gedenken an die Geschwister Scholl (Hans und Sophie) und ihre Freunde, die in der "Weiße Rose" gegen die Nazis aktiv waren. The family only allowed references to the first two charges but censored all references to the same-sex relationship. [2020 update: Traute is still linving on an island off the coast of South Carolina and will turn 101 in May.] On multiple occasions, during such excursions, as well as during the day, and in town, the two young men became sexual. What makes it assault? Jud Newborn spoke to the son of Söhngen’s closest friend who said Josef lived openly as a gay man after the war and his entire family was aware of it. In 2005, a German television survey voted Hans and Sophie the fourth greatest Germans of all time. Before his execution Hans wrote graffiti on his prison wall, quoting the classical liberal Goethe, “Stand firm against all powers that be.” He went to his death shouting, “Long live freedom.”. “You would have thought I accused Hans and Sophie of incest,” she whines. In addition, since 1945, many cities in both the Federal Republic of Germany as well as the German Democratic Republic have named streets, plazas and schools after the Scholl siblings. There was a consenting relationship between two teens of similar ages. Den auch in diesen Institutionen propagierten Rassismus hat SOPHIE schon früh nicht gebilligt. ... Geschwister Scholl - Geschwister Scholl Die Wei e Rose war der Name einer Widerstandsgruppe in M nchen w hrend der Zeit des Nationalsozialismus. Text: Fedor de Vries; Photos: Lennard Bolijn (1,2,3) & Fedor de Vries (4,5) She couldn’t bring herself to say homosexual or homosexuality and didn’t address what the first trial clearly exposed. Nach und nach traten alle Geschwister SCHOLL der Hitler-Jugend bzw. But, Sachs has her mind in the gutter. The Geschwister-Scholl-Preis is awarded annually in the auditorium of the university. Footnote:1. However, she soon took over important logistical work. Shared an apartment with his sister Sophie Scholl when he studied medicine at the University of Munich. Heeft u zelf meer informatie over deze persoon? He was defending Scholl, as Scholl was trying to defend him. He calls Hitler a great leader. She had bought into the homophobic idea gay men can’t be heroes. The Geschwister-Scholl-Institut at the Ludwig Maximilians University of Munich has been named in honor of Sophie and Hans Scholl. At points she seems to insert her obsessive accusations whether relevant or not. 18.2. In actuality, they are attached permanently to the ground in front of the main entrance on the so-called “Geschwister Scholl Platz.” “Geschwister Scholl” means basically “Scholl siblings.” Hans and Sophie Scholl were founding members of the student resistance movement to Hitler’s regime called “White Rose” (Weisse Rose). The Geschwister-Scholl Institute for Political Science within the University of Munich is named for Sophie and Hans Scholl. Resistance Figure. Hans had sent one of the leaflets of the White Rose to his own home in a direct mail campaign. 1921), Werner (b. Hij adviseerde het midden- en kleinbedrijf op het gebied van belastingen en andere handelsaangelegenheden. Hans Scholl, now a local leader of the Hitler Youth, used Lloyd George's comments to defend Hitler against his father.